4 Comments
User's avatar
Frank Lee's avatar

It is a class difference more than a political party difference. The moneyed elites occupy the Democrat party and the old GOP establishment. That has flipped over the last few decades as the Republican party used to be the party of the business class elite. But regardless, that top 10% are protective of the benefits of globalized corporate primacy and Wall Street control... despite the ongoing devastation to the lower 80%. MAGA is the Democrat-jettisoned forgotten working class that Trump brought to the GOP over anger that that top 10% kept up the destruction.

Our $1.4 trillion per year (real) trade deficit is as unsustainable as is our $2 trillion annual budget deficit... and directly related.

Global trade is good when the products and services are unique.

But globalism, including mass immigration, is a complete and utter failure.

The post Bretton Woods global order was good and worked well for the first 40 years, but NAFTA and China in the WTO was a massive break from that plan and corrupted the entire purpose to simply satiate upper class corporate and Wall Street greed.

There is no version of capitalism that ever supported turning domestic jobs into a global commodity. Capitalism as design is primarily a social system where domestic labor is supposed to share in the returns of domestic capital if only by the domestic jobs it creates. Exporting working class economic opportunity to other countries while importing the poverty of other countries... simply for the cheaper labor... was NEVER a part of any definition of true capitalism. It was a corporatist myth that capitalism supported the pursuit of profit at any cost to the domestic workforce.

The conflicts with trade are about economic opportunity for the majority. Most people understand that tariffs are a necessary tool to turn things around. There are other methods, but our feckless corporate-donor-addicted politicians will never go there.

Sorry, but cheap Chinese and Mexican-made goods on Amazon and at Walmart are not the American Dream.

Richard's avatar

For a lot of years after my economics degree, I was a free trade supporter. What finally convinced me otherwise was the supply chain issue. Combine that with Just in Time and you get a perfect storm. Free trade is more efficient but autarchy is a lot safer. We can't be totally self-reliant but we need to identify a lot of key resources where we need to approach that, especially where the product has a long lead time to set up production. One of life's ironies is that when *Biden put a gazillion dollars into infrastructure and manufacturing subsidies all the projects had such a long lead time as to minimize the political effect. As a bonus, it will start to reverse the hollowing out of middle America. The great sucking sound is part of the reason for the birth dearth. The inability to support a family on one working class job has had a devastating impact on family formation.

Xavier Narutowicz's avatar

Maybe, the rethinking of global trade policy has a lot to do with the US demise as a viable economic entity.

We are an unproductive consumer economy based on 40 trillion in debt that is lavished on an increasing lascivious population.

Carlton S.'s avatar

The issue should focus not on higher or lower tariffs overall, but rather on what tariffs should be applied to which countries, taking into consideration matters of national security in critical goods, as well as mutual economic benefits of trade with friendly nations based on the principle of comparative advantage. To the extent that jobs in some domestic industries have lower wages for them to be competitive, the gains from trade can be taxed and used to support higher wage subsidies through the earned income tax credit.