Thanksgiving travel is just around the corner, so we thought we’d start off with a couple of podcast suggestions.
Meredith Meroney recommends listening to Is AI Destroying the Next Generation of Leaders? (The Free Press School of War Podcast, also at Apple Podcasts):
In this conversation, CBS News’s Aaron MacLean and AEI’s Yuval Levin delve into the topic of how young professionals will become tomorrow’s leaders if AI replaces their entry- and mid-level jobs. Levin argues that people can only develop the competence, wisdom, and experience required to lead by doing the grunt work that professional workplaces can now (or will soon be able to) offload to AI.
“Doing mediocre work is how you become capable of doing excellent work,” Levin says. “Ultimately, human beings have to be formed. No one is born capable of high level work in any field.” He also argues that while AI models can do novice work, they can’t learn what novices learn: “tacit and implicit skills that are not as easily verifiable.”
We are still going to need human leaders and innovators in business and industry, STEM fields, government, religion, and academia. Levin says that developing leaders must become intentional and explicit. We won’t be able to rely on how leaders have been forged and brought up through our institutions in the past.
The flipside of this coin, which the podcast doesn’t address, is that today’s youth are cognitively offloading their learning by relying on AI to do school work. This will ultimately diminish their capacity to become more valuable than the AI coming for their jobs.
So, what do we do? After spending a decade as an independent school administrator, and eight years as a labor and employment attorney, including three years as senior counsel for labor relations at a major corporation, I have a few suggestions.
Parents and educators have a responsibility to help kids become lifelong learners and develop a growth mindset. This mindset helps students see working through challenges positively and learn to look at mistakes as learning opportunities. Students who have developed a growth mindset tend to avoid taking the easy way out to score good grades without doing the work. Independent schools are explicitly teaching children as young as five how to develop this mindset, but all schools need to do this and parents need to learn how as well. (Quick tip: praise effort not outcomes!)
Our youth also need to learn to value excellence over mediocrity, which unfortunately is rewarded all around us. We owe it to the next generation of Americans not to let technology degrade learning or to let schools degrade academic expectations because learning requires hard work.
In the workforce, if training entry-level professionals no longer makes financial sense (for example, paying first-year lawyers six-figure salaries to do work AI can now do), then we need to re-think professional education. We should focus on apprenticeship models in colleges and graduate schools. We also need to redirect our attention from the current workplace generational wars to strengthening intergenerational relationships that provide young workers with knowledge and wisdom that an AI model won’t learn and reproduce by devouring written texts.
Levin’s advice to young and mid-career professionals is good advice for everyone in our society navigating the impacts of AI: “Find ways to use [AI] to improve your work and to improve your abilities. But don’t let it replace you, not only as a worker, but as someone learning the craft you’re engaged in. Take the long way where you have a choice.”
For more insights from Yuval Levin, listen to his conversation about citizenship with our own Oren Cass and Chris Griswold on the American Compass Podcast.
Oren Cass recommends listening to Why Aren’t Young People Dating or Having Kids? (Cardus’s Policy & Proverbs Podcast, also at Apple Podcasts):
The decline in dating is a fascinating illustration of the vicious cycle a society can enter when it abandons communal norms, life scripts, and moral formation for belief in everyone’s ability to figure things out for themselves, which they cannot, which further erodes the very norms they might otherwise have relied upon. Christine Emba attributes the decline in dating to:
a disappearance of norms. In the post–Sexual Revolution world we had this belief that more freedom is better, more privacy is better, it’s great that nobody is looking over my shoulder when I go out on a date or telling me what to do. I can make up my own rules. But it turns out, especially in these emotionally fraught circumstances, knowing what the rules are and what you’re supposed to do is actually really helpful. It can be extremely daunting to make it up by yourself as you go along.
The problem with the hypothetically welfare-maximizing model of everyone doing their own thing is that most people don’t do their own thing, they just end up with nothing.
Johnny Burtka recommends watching the second leg of the Concacaf Nations League Quarterfinals between the U.S. Men’s National Team and Haiti on Tuesday at 7:00pm EST:
What can soccer teach us about renewing federalism in America? I never thought I’d ask that question, but since the World Cup came to the United States last summer, I’ve gone completely “soccer-mad.” Apparently, I’m not alone. According to a new report from Major League Soccer (MLS), live television viewership is up a whopping 93% year over year, and there has been 10% growth in self-identifying American soccer fans since the World Cup, with Gen Z seeing the largest gains.
Soccer has two distinctive features that serve as a model for federalism.
First, players compete for “club and country” in a unique way compared to other professional sports. While primary loyalties lie with local clubs, the best players are called-up to play for their national teams, typically during four international breaks each year. During these breaks, duty to country takes precedence over local loyalties. For example, in late September and early October, MLS players missed club team matches midseason to play for their national teams. While MLS has taken a pause for the Concacaf Quarterfinals, players still sacrifice training time with their clubs and risk injury on the pitch for their countries just days before the MLS playoffs begin. The fact that fans, clubs, and managers celebrate the pursuit of national honor in this way demonstrates patriotism, rightly ordered.
Second, clubs are incentivized to foster homegrown talent. Bypassing the college-for-all model that’s the hallmark of NBA and NFL recruitment, professional soccer clubs have their own youth academies where players as young as eight years old train. Select clubs, like the Philadelphia Union (DOOP!), have partnerships with schools located on or near their campus to provide free, merit-based education to students training at their soccer academies. This approach encourages stewardship of the local community and fosters regional pride–in the case of Philadelphia, one-third of their first-team line-up came through their youth academy.
It’s a rare thing in contemporary American life to see the principle of federalism alive and well, but soccer is an exception to that rule. From youth academies to clubs to the national team, healthy and well-ordered attachments flourish at their appropriate levels. When Cavan Sullivan and Neil Pierre take the pitch for the United States Men’s National Team this week, both products of the Union Academy, my allegiance to region, club, and country will be perfectly aligned.
Drew Holden notes IBM’s pro-America hiring shift (Newsweek):
Big Tech has been in the Trump administration’s crosshairs for all sorts of well-deserved reasons lately. Perhaps most encouraging has been the crackdown on the abuse of America’s H-1B visa system, where domestic companies can sponsor foreign workers to fill technical jobs. Major domestic companies have used the program to import cheap labor without any evidence of a labor “shortage,” even sometimes laying off American workers in parallel.
The public reprimanding of Microsoft by Vice President JD Vance may be starting to move the needle. Rather than risk the kinds of legal consequences now facing Microsoft, Adobe, and others, IBM voluntarily ended the company’s use of the visa in its consulting division, citing changes to “skill availability and client need.” There’s only so many roses worth giving a company surely making these changes under duress, but the decision chips away at the edifice of our corrupt work-visa program and validates the administration’s push. Hopefully other companies will follow.
YOUR CONCLUDING THOUGHT FROM RECLAIMING AMERICAN CITIZENSHIP:
What is our positive, concrete vision for the essential elements of a good life? Reclaiming American citizenship begins with the assertion that it is worth reclaiming and the articulation of the substantive ends toward which communal, economic, and national life must lead:
We reject isolation and atomization. Promising people radical autonomy and the right to define their own truth has left them disconnected from each other and from reality. We choose instead laws and a culture that reward success along well-defined paths through life, supported by meaningful relationships and institutions refocused on their purpose.



As someone who had done a lot of labor negotiations, I am unimpressed with the accomplishments of lawyers in the field. I had to spend a fair amount of time cleaning up messes. Perhaps bond lawyers who actually understand numbers could accomplish something.