Earlier this month, voters across America repudiated Donald Trump’s Republican Party in one of the most stinging electoral rebukes of modern times. The carnage was particularly notable in the so-called Bible Belt, where formerly rock-ribbed Republican states, brimming over with religiously devout social conservatives, flipped blue for the first time in decades.
The suburban county where I grew up, Spartanburg County, South Carolina, is home to perhaps the only Barnes & Noble that still has a larger section dedicated to Bibles than to manga, yet it swung left by an almost incredible 29 points from 2024 to 2026. The so-called “religious Left,” a nonentity in national politics for over a decade, suddenly rose from the dead in the midterms, with deep-red Kansas voting for megachurch pastor Adam Hamilton to become its first Democratic senator since the Great Depression. In Texas, Democrat James Talarico, campaigning openly on his Christian faith, absolutely trounced Ken Paxton in a state full of evangelical leaders, one of whom confessed to me last month that he couldn’t bring himself to vote for the scandal-plagued Paxton and would probably sit this one out.
He wasn’t alone. White evangelicals made up only 17% of the midterm vote share, collapsing from 23% in 2024. Catholics, meanwhile, still voted, but swung left by 21 points. The values voter, it seems, can no longer be counted upon to show up and deliver wins for the GOP.
In this, however, lies a ray of hope for the Right—or indeed for any political movement courageous enough to capitalize on the current malaise. The American people are increasingly disgusted with what their economy has become, and poll after poll has shown them hungry for regulations to rein in its excesses. Just as religious conservatives and liberal crusaders joined together in the temperance movement of the late nineteenth century, combining forces to combat corporate greed and personal degeneracy, perhaps it is time for conservatives and progressives to find common cause in mapping out a new temperance agenda to tame our new vice economy.
Conservatives would be wrong to conclude from the midterms that it’s time to abandon morality for “kitchen table issues.” The reality is that for many families, the kitchen table issues are moral issues: the teenaged daughter who developed an eating disorder from TikTok, the adult son living in the basement who can’t hold down a job because of his weed and pornography addictions and loses what little money he earns betting on FanDuel, or the younger son who doesn’t understand why it’s considered cheating to use Google Gemini on his school-issued Chromebook to do all his homework.
Our markets, rather than serving American families, are tearing them apart, and American voters are primed for leaders willing to rein in an economy that caters to appetite and impulse rather than genuine human needs. Rather than narrowing our moral message, it’s time to broaden it—and with it, our coalition.
A Moral Minority?
The family today is under unrelenting assault from nearly every direction, with children bombarded by porn stars when they open up their social media feeds and by gambling ads and betting advice when they try to watch their favorite sports team. Over the past 50 years, the American economy has shifted from a manufacturing economy to a service economy, and increasingly from a service economy to a vice economy—and American families are paying the price.
Some Republican strategists have concluded that the days of values voting are over, that the “Moral Majority” of the 1980s has been reduced to a permanent moral minority, and the Right’s only hope lay in rebranding itself as the party of Barstool Sports and Kalshi. Hoping to woo younger and more libertine voters, the party has spent recent years deregulating everything from marijuana to OnlyFans, but this strategy has not correlated with electoral success: No demographic abandoned the Republican Party in the midterms more decisively than young men, the prime customers of the vice economy, who swung left by an astounding 34%. Why haven’t the most avid users of gambling apps rewarded the president who helped proliferate their use?
To ask the question, however, is to answer it, for it is of the essence of vice industries that customers themselves often detest their own usage. In a 2024 Harris poll, 40% of Gen Zers said they wished social media had never been invented—a number that rose to 50% for some of the most popular platforms. The junkie, as we all know, is not a rational actor, and we have increasingly become a society of junkies.
The Economics of Vice
Vice, as I wrote previously in Commonplace, breaks the core assumptions of free market capitalism. One of the premises of a healthy economy is that producers can only profit by meeting people’s needs, which tends to set an upper limit on profits. Ordinarily, human desires are limited by what is called “diminishing marginal utility”—a second Chick-fil-A sandwich is not nearly as desirable to me as the first. This phenomenon means that a producer can only continue to increase profits to the extent that he (a) finds new customers, (b) develops new or improved products, or (c) finds a way to reduce his costs—all of which are beneficial to an economy and a society. But what if you could flip the demand curve? What if consumers would pay $4 for a single sandwich, $10 for a second, and $20 for a third? Then you would have yourself a money machine, a highly efficient mechanism for transferring wealth from the pockets of ordinary consumers into the pockets of whatever genius figured out how to make that magic meal.
Of course, this is exactly what tech industry titans have figured out how to do. They haven’t yet done it for sandwiches—perhaps because the Food and Drug Administration would have a thing or two to say about lacing your chicken with opioids—but in the largely unregulated digital economy, many of our best entrepreneurs have been devoted toward figuring how to turn one-hour scrollers into two-hour scrollers and two-hour scrollers into four-hour scrollers. Based on all the data available to us, they have become frighteningly good at it. Nearly half of American teens report being online “almost constantly,” and the merchants of vice have flooded into this digital space with ever-improved ways of taking advantage of consumers in a Pavlovian stupor. The rise of sports gambling, prediction markets, and cryptocurrency day trading is built on the frictionless interface of the smartphone, which often allows users to indulge in vice anonymously.
The result is an ever-expanding K-shaped addiction economy, in which ordinary citizens feel stuck, scammed, and disempowered, and a handful of billionaires become centi-billionaires, dragging on their coattails anyone in Washington clever enough to cash in on access to power. Legislators have rushed to deregulate and legalize the latest vice du jour, so as not to miss out on the campaign donations.
This observation, I believe, helps make sense of the staggering 90% of midterm voters who said that corruption was a “major” or “crucial” factor in their vote, with those most concerned voting most Democratic.
The Politics of Vice
What does vice do to a political society? The same thing it does to an individual. Just as the individual becomes hooked on the quick hit, reflexively pulling the lever against his own long-term interests, so does a political society. For many state and local governments, this can be quite concretely tied to the vice industry in question. A jurisdiction that legalizes the lottery in lieu of the more painful work of collecting tax revenues elsewhere will find that it can’t break its habit any more than the impoverished citizen who spends the first dollars of every paycheck on lottery tickets.
A state that decides to welcome gambling or marijuana in return for a small cut of every transaction is liable to become addicted to the industry every bit as much as its residents are. Hooked on the easy revenue, it mortgages its people’s future to pay for the present. It stops investing in good industries and rewarding good jobs. It stops making the hard political choices that involve give-and-take with voters, wooing new residents and businesses with ever-lower income taxes or property taxes, and hoping the vice revenue will fill the gap.
Just as for the individual weighing whether to smoke his first joint, fear of missing out plays a major role: If my state’s residents are crossing the border or logging online to gamble anyway, I might as well join in on the fun.
The short-term nature of a vice society also tends to afflict its political judgment more generally. Long time horizons, which our species has always struggled to keep in focus, disappear from view under the glare of the news cycle and political hot takes. Pulling the lever in a voting booth starts to feel like pulling the lever of a slot machine: The electorate expect immediate results, and when it doesn’t happen, voters discontentedly switch parties. The only thing surprising about this particular midterm wave was its scale. Politicians, in turn, respond by abandoning long-term governance and resorting to gimmicks, like a drug dealer handing out samples of the newest synthetic opioid for his junkies. President Trump promised voters a $5,000 cash gift if they gave the GOP an unlikely midterm victory, while jittery bond markets eyed near-record budget deficits.
Artificial intelligence has become the latest performance-enhancing drug by which our political leaders hope to juice the body politic at the cost of our long-term capacity for self-government. Dazed by the promise of easy money and power as new tech giants build out trillions of dollars worth of compute, leaders in Washington have resisted calls to regulate AI deepfakes and sexbots even as state legislators sought to respond to these new vices. With polls showing between 80% and 90% bipartisan support for stricter AI regulations, advocates and political consultants alike have expressed surprise that any administration could act so brazenly against the public will.
A New Temperance Agenda
These numbers, however, offer reason for hope. Today, there is a wide-raging war taking place between humanism and anti-humanism, in which markets of unprecedented scale have emerged around the commodification of young women’s bodies and young men’s competitive instincts, in which family formation is eviscerated by devices promising effortless simulated connection, and in which GDP growth is being driven largely by a new industry that seeks to profit by replacing humanity with digital clones.
The simmering discontent with this increasingly post-human economy may not have been clearly reflected yet in exit polls, as pollsters struggle to even frame their questions in ways that capture the growing unease, but it stands poised to reshape our politics in a way that transcends religious affiliation and crosses party lines. Beneath this discontent lie two intuitions. The first, a traditionally conservative instinct, recognizes that liberty is not the same as license, and that a society of people who chronically indulge their appetites is not one that can sustain healthy families or form mature citizens. The second, a traditionally progressive instinct, recognizes that big business will go wherever the profit margins are fattest, and if that means finding a market of addicts, they will corner it if at all possible. Both intuitions recognize that too little of our economy is truly a “free market” as extolled by economists and politicians. Vice is a machine built for exploiting human weakness, dismembering families, and infantilizing citizens.
Awakening to such crises of capitalism in the past, Americans across religious and partisan divides mobilized against Big Alcohol and Big Tobacco in ways that won lasting victories for American families and American democracy. Today, we have the opportunity to tap into a similarly deep well of moral outrage and build a durable political movement. From marijuana to TikTok, from pornography to prediction markets, it is increasingly clear that the products proliferating fastest across our economy offer little to no utility to consumers. They do so while promising massive profits to a handful of monopolistic platforms that make heavy donations to politicians in hopes they will turn a blind eye to the excesses.
While skeptics may object that Americans will never stand for vice regulation, our history suggests otherwise. Most voters may not like moral scolds, but if they get wind that billionaires are making a mint out of exploiting moral weakness, they know how to connect the dots between personal vice, predatory markets, and political corruption—and can clean house in a hurry.
A new temperance agenda, then, will involve a broad-based attack on the new vice industries that are tearing apart the American family. Given the smartphone’s centrality as a digital vector, the first steps should start there. The route has already been mapped out over the past few years by the so-called kids’ online safety movement. But the real issue goes deeper than “safety,” it is a question of how much we will allow online markets weaponized for addiction to access the most vulnerable among us. The modus vivendi we have established with many addictive substances is to allow them for adults but ban them for children; it’s time to apply this rule online as well.
But we do not have to leave adults entirely to their own devices either. We should stop treating online prostitution as “protected speech,” stop euphemizing sports betting as “commodity futures trading,” and stop treating marijuana as a harmless stimulant. Where it is not wise or viable to ban an exploitative market entirely, we can reintroduce frictions to give the better angels of our nature a fighting chance: restricting licensing, taxation, and advertising of digital vice.
Where we have the opportunity to shape new industries in their infancy, such as artificial intelligence, we should take stern measures to channel innovation away from deepfakes and digital girlfriends and toward applications that empower workers, citizens, and parents. With voters outraged over the unregulated proliferation of antisocial AI, a backlash seems to be growing against the antihuman incentives that have taken root across our economy.
Because such backlashes blend both conservative and progressive instincts, they do not automatically redound to the benefit of one political party. During the so-called Progressive Era (roughly 1890-1920), Theodore Roosevelt’s visionary politics capitalized on the moral fervor of the temperance movement and the populist rage against trusts to build a powerful coalition—until the Republican Party’s 1912 split enabled Woodrow Wilson’s Democrats to take advantage. So it is today: We stand at a moment of radical political reset, in which the lane is wide open for whichever party is willing to set its face against the vice economy and treat the next generation as our most priceless possession rather than a resource to be extracted. Who will rise to the challenge first?





Not sure the temperance movement is a great metaphor as the culmination was generally regarded as a disaster. It is hard to argue though that things aren't badly broken. I would prefer a solution that doesn't depend on government coercion but on the hearts of the people. Though I am not involved with religion, I think a religious revival would be the best option. The bad news is that I don't have a clue how to make it happen.
Add to the list of vices the extreme violence and brutality common now in film, TV, games, everywhere. Start applying the same content rules online that apply to broadcast TV. Also, start applying the NC-17 label a lot more often.
I'm old enough to remember when The Godfather was first shown on TV, and there was some controversy over its suitability for prime time, such as should it include the scene of Sonny being killed at the toll booth? I recall the scene was edited somehow so you only heard the gunfire but did not see anything graphic. After hearing the sound of gunfire you saw some cars driving away. Good times.
Nowadays, kids of all ages can see everything and anything at anytime. Its awful.